The Best Supernatural Games - Page 2

Update : Carnival added at rank #41.
11

Tell Me Why (2020)

View Similar Games
86
Review score
Logo of Tell Me Why Screenshot of Tell Me Why Screenshot of Tell Me Why Screenshot of Tell Me Why

PC Windows Xbox One

Unravel the mysteries of 'Tell Me Why', a narrative adventure game that explores the emotional journey of twins Tyler and Alyson. Your choices shape their lives and their supernatural bond. Dive into an Alaskan setting, solve puzzles, and navigate through their fantasy world. Experience an emotionally intelligent game with beautiful graphics and a well-crafted story.


What we like:
  • Emotionally rich narrative
  • Beautiful, immersive graphics
  • Impactful player choices
  • Excellent voice acting
  • Respectful LGBTQ+ representation
What could be improved:
  • Similar mechanics to previous games
  • Outdated character models
  • Emotional pacing can be inconsistent

  • narrative
  • supernatural
  • episodic
  • adventure
  • mystery
  • drama
  • choices
  • puzzle
  • story
  • mature
  • lgbtq
  • exploration
  • true-to-life
  • walking-simulator

12

Unavowed (2018)

View Similar Games
87
Review score
Logo of Unavowed Screenshot of Unavowed Screenshot of Unavowed Screenshot of Unavowed

Linux Nintendo Switch Mac OS PC Windows

A demon has possessed you and used your body to tear a swath of bloodshed through New York. You are now free, but life as you knew it is over. Your only path forward is joining the Unavowed - an ancient society dedicated to stopping evil. No matter what the cost.


  • supernatural
  • point-and-click
  • adventure
  • puzzle
  • pixel
  • detective
  • fantasy
  • graphic
  • mystery

13

Ghost Master (2022)

View Similar Games
75
Review score
Logo of Ghost Master Screenshot of Ghost Master Screenshot of Ghost Master Screenshot of Ghost Master

Xbox One PC Windows

Spirit Detective is a realistic Oriental culture, 1V5 asymmetric competitive game launched by (Hong Kong)GKD. The game is based on the all-embracing traditional Oriental culture and designed to let players experience the charm of traditional Oriental strange culture.


  • horror
  • supernatural
  • strategy
  • simulation
  • cooperative
  • mature
  • royale
  • gore
  • hack-and-slash
  • pvp
  • survival-horror
  • puzzle
  • psychological
  • zombies

14

Mutazione (2019)

View Similar Games
90
Review score
Logo of Mutazione Screenshot of Mutazione Screenshot of Mutazione Screenshot of Mutazione

PC Windows Nintendo Switch Xbox One Linux Mac OS IOS iPhone Playstation 4

Get lost in the magical world of Mutazione, a narrative-driven adventure game where you explore an island filled with quirky mutant characters and their secrets. Grow musical gardens, attend BBQs, and embark on a spiritual journey to save the community from a looming darkness. With beautiful hand-illustrated art and unpredictable twists, Mutazione is a mutant soap opera that you won't want to miss.


What we like:
  • Unique and beautiful art style
  • Relaxing music
  • Story-focused gameplay
  • Quirky and interesting characters
  • Encourages the player to slow down and relax
What could be improved:
  • Repetitive gameplay, mostly a visual novel
  • No voice acting
  • Slow parts may be boring for some players
  • Contains adult themes that may not be suitable for younger children

  • drama
  • narrative
  • supernatural
  • relaxing
  • adventure
  • walking-simulator
  • point-and-click
  • nature
  • exploration
  • fiction
  • music
  • story
  • scroller
  • bird
  • procedural

15

Oxenfree (2016)

View Similar Games
90
Review score
Logo of Oxenfree Screenshot of Oxenfree Screenshot of Oxenfree Screenshot of Oxenfree

Android Linux Mac OS PC Windows Xbox One IOS iPhone

Oxenfree is a supernatural thriller about a group of friends who unwittingly open a ghostly rift. You are Alex, and you’ve just brought your new stepbrother Jonas to an overnight island party gone horribly wrong.


  • supernatural
  • mystery
  • horror
  • narrative
  • military
  • adventure

16

Ghost Town (2021)

View Similar Games
87
Review score
Logo of Ghost Town Screenshot of Ghost Town Screenshot of Ghost Town Screenshot of Ghost Town

j PC Windows IOS iPhone Android

Ghost Town is a single player VR puzzle-adventure from the makers of The Room. London, 1983. Edith Penrose is a ghost hunter, busy exorcising her way through the city's restless spirits. But after her brother goes missing Edith must draw upon her wits & supernatural talents to unravel the mystery.


  • vr
  • 1980s
  • supernatural
  • cinematic
  • magic
  • atmospheric
  • mystery
  • detective
  • puzzle
  • investigation
  • horror
  • linear
  • tactile
  • story
  • demons

17

Enigma of Fear (2024)

View Similar Games
67
Review score
Logo of Enigma of Fear Screenshot of Enigma of Fear Screenshot of Enigma of Fear Screenshot of Enigma of Fear

PC Windows

Become Mia, a paranormal detective searching for her missing father inside the Perimeter - a place that doesn't exist. Investigate clues like a real detective and unravel the mysteries behind the Enigma of Fear, defeating the terrible monsters who'll try to stop you.

Buy

  • investigation
  • mystery
  • dog
  • detective
  • supernatural
  • survival-horror
  • visual-novel
  • travel
  • multiple-endings
  • open-world
  • pixel
  • music
  • time
  • isometric
  • hand-drawn

18

The Darkside Detective (2017)

View Similar Games
86
Review score
Logo of The Darkside Detective Screenshot of The Darkside Detective Screenshot of The Darkside Detective Screenshot of The Darkside Detective

PC Windows Xbox One Playstation 5 Playstation 4 stadia Nintendo Switch Linux Mac OS IOS iPhone

Join Detectives McQueen and Dooley as they solve six different cases full of humour and great references in the town of Twin Lakes. With beautiful retro-style pixel graphics, this is a must play for lovers of cats, coffee and all kinds of videogames!


What we like:
  • Crisp and clean pixel graphics
  • Variety in music
  • Sense of satisfaction when solving a case
  • Humourous atmosphere
  • Great movie references
What could be improved:
  • Cases are straightforward
  • Not super challenging
  • No tries to scare you

  • point-and-click
  • detective
  • supernatural
  • pixel
  • adventure
  • funny
  • retro
  • mystery
  • puzzle
  • comedy

19

Life is Strange Remastered Collection (2022)

View Similar Games
85
Review score
Logo of Life is Strange Remastered Collection Screenshot of Life is Strange Remastered Collection Screenshot of Life is Strange Remastered Collection Screenshot of Life is Strange Remastered Collection

Nintendo Switch Playstation 4 stadia PC Windows Xbox One

Experience the BAFTA award-winning story of Life is Strange now beautifully remastered with enhanced visuals and vastly improved animation using mocap technology.


  • episodic
  • narrative
  • story
  • supernatural
  • drama
  • choices
  • adventure
  • mystery
  • romance
  • puzzle

20

Creaks (2020)

View Similar Games
91
Review score
Logo of Creaks Screenshot of Creaks Screenshot of Creaks Screenshot of Creaks

Mac OS IOS iPhone PC Windows Playstation 4 Nintendo Switch

The ground starts shaking, light bulbs are breaking - and something rather unusual is happening right behind the walls of your very room. Equipped with nothing but wit and courage, you slowly descend into a world inhabited by avian folk and seemingly deadly furniture monsters.


  • hand-drawn
  • puzzle
  • surreal
  • stylized
  • supernatural
  • platform
  • atmospheric
  • linear
  • cartoony
  • relaxing
  • 2d
  • mystery
  • story
  • dark
  • single-player

Not seeing your game?