The Best Supernatural Games - Page 3

Update : Carnival added at rank #41.
21

Paper Ghost Stories: Third Eye Open (2024)

View Similar Games
ND
Review score
Logo of Paper Ghost Stories: Third Eye Open Screenshot of Paper Ghost Stories: Third Eye Open Screenshot of Paper Ghost Stories: Third Eye Open Screenshot of Paper Ghost Stories: Third Eye Open

Xbox One Nintendo Switch Playstation 5 PC Windows

Third Eye Open is a supernatural narrative adventure about a young girl coming of age. The game is set in a small Malaysian suburb which the player navigates to speak to friends, families, and ghosts. Various minigames immerse the player deeper into the protagonist's journey.


  • supernatural
  • conversation
  • 2.5d
  • fiction
  • thriller
  • emotional
  • choices
  • drama
  • stealth
  • hand-drawn
  • action-adventure
  • stylized
  • interactive
  • story
  • exploration

22

Unpossess: Exorcism Simulator (2025)

View Similar Games
75
Review score
Logo of Unpossess: Exorcism Simulator Screenshot of Unpossess: Exorcism Simulator Screenshot of Unpossess: Exorcism Simulator Screenshot of Unpossess: Exorcism Simulator

early access PC Windows Android

Unpossess is a 1-4 co-op exorcism simulator game set in the early 1900s. Players take on the role of exorcists responsible for addressing cases of human possession.


  • horror
  • dark
  • supernatural
  • cooperative
  • demons
  • psychological
  • thriller
  • survival-horror
  • realistic
  • simulation
  • horror-adventure
  • immersive
  • fantasy
  • multiplayer

23

The Wild Case (2021)

View Similar Games
87
Review score
Logo of The Wild Case Screenshot of The Wild Case Screenshot of The Wild Case Screenshot of The Wild Case

PC Windows Nintendo Switch Android IOS iPhone Mac OS Linux

Embark on a journey to an eerie village shrouded in mystery in The Wild Case. Solve puzzles, negotiate with inhabitants, and uncover supernatural occurrences in this atmospheric adventure. With stunning hand-drawn graphics and haunting sound effects, immerse yourself in an open world that will keep you on edge. Unravel the secrets of the forgotten village if you dare.


What we like:
  • Short but well-rounded gameplay
  • Intriguing mystery with satisfying ending
  • Beautiful hand-drawn artwork
  • Atmospheric music and sound effects
  • Adequate price point
What could be improved:
  • Lack of motivation for replayability
  • Rough English translation
  • Story not frightening for adults

  • detective
  • point-and-click
  • puzzle
  • story
  • hand-drawn
  • adventure
  • atmospheric
  • text
  • supernatural
  • 2d
  • mystery
  • exploration
  • first-person
  • investigation
  • linear

24

3 Minutes to Midnight (2024)

View Similar Games
81
Review score
Logo of 3 Minutes to Midnight Screenshot of 3 Minutes to Midnight Screenshot of 3 Minutes to Midnight Screenshot of 3 Minutes to Midnight

PC Windows Linux Mac OS IOS iPhone Android Nintendo Switch Xbox One Playstation 5 Playstation 4

In a race against time, Betty embarks on a thrilling, comedy-packed adventure to crack a conspiracy that starts with a bang and ends at 3 Minutes to Midnight.

Buy

  • choices
  • point-and-click
  • supernatural
  • adventure
  • multiple-endings
  • conspiracy
  • cartoony
  • narration
  • hand-drawn
  • comedy
  • nonlinear
  • story
  • puzzle
  • drama
  • funny

25

The Chant (2022)

View Similar Games
73
Review score
Logo of The Chant Screenshot of The Chant Screenshot of The Chant Screenshot of The Chant

PC Windows Android Xbox Series X Playstation 5

A single-player, third person horror action-adventure game set on a remote spiritual island retreat. To survive you must craft, fight, and escape the psychedelic horrors set loose when a spiritual ritual goes wrong and awakens a dimension of cosmic terror.


  • horror
  • survival-horror
  • supernatural
  • cult
  • action-adventure
  • third-person
  • psychological
  • emotional
  • exploration

26

This is a Ghost (2024)

View Similar Games
91
Review score
Logo of This is a Ghost Screenshot of This is a Ghost Screenshot of This is a Ghost Screenshot of This is a Ghost

PC Windows

This is a Ghost is a supernatural investigation game. You are a member of a secret society that hunts or sets free scary entities from our world. Gather evidence, identify the entity and send it back to the afterlife. Playable in Solo and co-op : 1 to 4 players.

Buy

  • investigation
  • horror
  • cooperative
  • supernatural
  • lovecraftian
  • psychological
  • thriller
  • demons
  • detective
  • dark
  • 3d
  • mystery
  • realistic
  • tactical
  • first-person

27

The Haunting of Joni Evers (2025)

View Similar Games
ND
Review score
Logo of The Haunting of Joni Evers Screenshot of The Haunting of Joni Evers Screenshot of The Haunting of Joni Evers Screenshot of The Haunting of Joni Evers

PC Windows Mac OS

The Haunting of Joni Evers is an emotional tale of a broken family from small-town Oklahoma, driven apart by a malevolent haunting. Uncover the mysteries of Joni’s family and the Cunningham House, digging through memories, facing the family’s past to break the curse.

Buy

  • walking-simulator
  • supernatural
  • short
  • emotional
  • narration
  • fiction
  • visual-novel
  • horror
  • psychological
  • mystery
  • drama
  • story
  • atmospheric
  • interactive
  • exploration

28

Occult Crime Police (2021)

View Similar Games
93
Review score
Logo of Occult Crime Police Screenshot of Occult Crime Police Screenshot of Occult Crime Police Screenshot of Occult Crime Police

IOS iPhone PC Windows Mac OS Linux

Murder. Conspiracy. Thought Influencers. Only you can decipher the mystery of Base 24. Comb a mysterious government base for evidence, catch suspects in their lies, and unravel the truth, no matter how ridiculous it may be!

Buy

  • cartoony
  • supernatural
  • detective
  • investigation
  • visual-novel
  • lgbtq
  • point-and-click
  • mystery
  • hand-drawn
  • funny
  • anime
  • 2d
  • conversation
  • story
  • sci-fi

29

Dark Nights with Poe and Munro (2020)

View Similar Games
74
Review score
Logo of Dark Nights with Poe and Munro Screenshot of Dark Nights with Poe and Munro Screenshot of Dark Nights with Poe and Munro Screenshot of Dark Nights with Poe and Munro

Linux Mac OS Nintendo Switch Playstation 4 Xbox One PC Windows

Guide radio hosts Poe and Munro through six episodes of supernatural FMV adventure in the strange town of August! From the creators of award winning FMV games The Infectious Madness of Doctor Dekker and The Shapeshifting Detective.


  • supernatural
  • choices
  • fmv
  • episodic
  • fiction
  • cinematic
  • interactive
  • mystery
  • horror
  • detective
  • investigation
  • multiple-endings
  • telltale
  • comedy
  • drama

30

Restless Nights (2024)

View Similar Games
ND
Review score
Logo of Restless Nights Screenshot of Restless Nights Screenshot of Restless Nights Screenshot of Restless Nights

PC Windows

The Shadow Stalker is out to get you, but why? Try to fall asleep while fixing anomalies around the house and keeping the fireplace lit in this horror experience as you uncover the truth of why your being haunted. How long can you survive?

Buy

  • survival-horror
  • horror
  • supernatural
  • atmospheric
  • walking-simulator
  • dark
  • nonlinear
  • time-management
  • perma-death
  • first-person
  • mystery
  • single-player
  • resource-management

Not seeing your game?