The Best Supernatural Games

Update : Carnival added at rank #46.
1

The Painscreek Killings (2017)

View Similar Games
94
Review score
Logo of The Painscreek Killings Screenshot of The Painscreek Killings Screenshot of The Painscreek Killings Screenshot of The Painscreek Killings

PC Windows

Investigate an infamous cold case in the eerie, abandoned town of Painscreek. Search for evidence, connect the dots and uncover who killed Vivian Roberts. Can you expose the truth behind this town’s dark secrets?


  • detective
  • investigation
  • supernatural
  • mystery
  • walking-simulator
  • walking
  • open-world
  • atmospheric
  • conspiracy
  • exploration
  • story
  • narration
  • adventure
  • thriller
  • 3d

2

Occult Crime Police (2021)

View Similar Games
93
Review score
Logo of Occult Crime Police Screenshot of Occult Crime Police Screenshot of Occult Crime Police Screenshot of Occult Crime Police

IOS iPhone PC Windows Mac OS Linux

Murder. Conspiracy. Thought Influencers. Only you can decipher the mystery of Base 24. Comb a mysterious government base for evidence, catch suspects in their lies, and unravel the truth, no matter how ridiculous it may be!

Buy

  • cartoony
  • supernatural
  • detective
  • investigation
  • visual-novel
  • lgbtq
  • point-and-click
  • mystery
  • hand-drawn
  • funny
  • anime
  • 2d
  • conversation
  • story
  • sci-fi

3

Life is Strange: Before the Storm (2017)

View Similar Games
93
Review score
Logo of Life is Strange: Before the Storm Screenshot of Life is Strange: Before the Storm Screenshot of Life is Strange: Before the Storm Screenshot of Life is Strange: Before the Storm

Nintendo Switch Linux Mac OS Playstation 4 Xbox One PC Windows

Life is Strange: Before the Storm is a new three part standalone story adventure set three years before the events of the first game. This time play as Chloe Price, a rebel who forms an unlikely friendship with Rachel Amber in a dramatic new story in the BAFTA award winning franchise.


  • episodic
  • narrative
  • supernatural
  • story
  • choices
  • drama
  • mystery
  • adventure
  • romance
  • puzzle
  • graphic

4

A Space for the Unbound - Prologue (2020)

View Similar Games
92
Review score
Logo of A Space for the Unbound - Prologue Screenshot of A Space for the Unbound - Prologue Screenshot of A Space for the Unbound - Prologue Screenshot of A Space for the Unbound - Prologue

Mac OS PC Windows

Prologue chapter of A Space For The Unbound, an upcoming slice-of-life adventure game with beautiful pixelart set in the late 90s rural Indonesia that tells a story about overcoming anxiety, depression, and the relationship between a boy and a girl with supernatural powers


  • 1990s
  • foreign
  • emotional
  • philosophical
  • supernatural
  • pixel
  • walking-simulator
  • surreal
  • relaxing
  • story
  • atmospheric
  • action-adventure
  • 2d
  • point-and-click
  • anime

5

Creaks (2020)

View Similar Games
91
Review score
Logo of Creaks Screenshot of Creaks Screenshot of Creaks Screenshot of Creaks

Mac OS IOS iPhone PC Windows Playstation 4 Nintendo Switch

The ground starts shaking, light bulbs are breaking - and something rather unusual is happening right behind the walls of your very room. Equipped with nothing but wit and courage, you slowly descend into a world inhabited by avian folk and seemingly deadly furniture monsters.


  • hand-drawn
  • puzzle
  • surreal
  • stylized
  • supernatural
  • platform
  • atmospheric
  • linear
  • cartoony
  • relaxing
  • 2d
  • mystery
  • story
  • dark
  • single-player

6

This is a Ghost (2024)

View Similar Games
91
Review score
Logo of This is a Ghost Screenshot of This is a Ghost Screenshot of This is a Ghost Screenshot of This is a Ghost

PC Windows

This is a Ghost is a supernatural investigation game. You are a member of a secret society that hunts or sets free scary entities from our world. Gather evidence, identify the entity and send it back to the afterlife. Playable in Solo and co-op : 1 to 4 players.

Buy

  • investigation
  • horror
  • cooperative
  • supernatural
  • lovecraftian
  • psychological
  • thriller
  • demons
  • detective
  • dark
  • 3d
  • mystery
  • realistic
  • tactical
  • first-person

7

The Rewinder (2021)

View Similar Games
91
Review score
Logo of The Rewinder Screenshot of The Rewinder Screenshot of The Rewinder Screenshot of The Rewinder

j PC Windows Mac OS Nintendo Switch Xbox One Xbox Series X

The Rewinder is an adventure puzzle game based on Chinese mythology. You play as Yun, the last known Rewinder, who can communicate with spirits and explore other people's memories to alter the past.


  • pixel
  • point-and-click
  • drama
  • detective
  • mythology
  • thriller
  • puzzle
  • mystery
  • 2d
  • lore
  • supernatural
  • atmospheric
  • adventure
  • horror
  • comedy

8

At Dead Of Night (2020)

View Similar Games
91
Review score
Logo of At Dead Of Night Screenshot of At Dead Of Night Screenshot of At Dead Of Night Screenshot of At Dead Of Night

PC Windows

At Dead Of Night is part horror film, part horror game and part ghost hunt. It blends live-action and graphics to create a unique immersive horror experience like no other. Steam Deck version now available (yet to be Steam reviewed - current review is for the non-optimised game).

Buy

  • investigation
  • survival-horror
  • supernatural
  • gothic
  • tactical
  • fmv
  • horror
  • cinematic
  • point-and-click
  • strategy
  • atmospheric
  • first-person
  • rpg
  • mystery
  • real-time

9

Life is Strange: True Colors (2021)

View Similar Games
90
Review score
Logo of Life is Strange: True Colors Screenshot of Life is Strange: True Colors Screenshot of Life is Strange: True Colors Screenshot of Life is Strange: True Colors

Playstation 4 IOS iPhone Xbox Series X Xbox One PC Windows stadia Nintendo Switch Playstation 5

Experience a bold new era in the award-winning Life is Strange series with Life is Strange: True Colors. Uncover the shocking secrets behind your brother's death as you navigate through an emotional roller-coaster of an adventure. Harness the power of Empathy to change fate and forge deep relationships with the townsfolk. Make tough decisions, explore the vibrant town of Haven Springs, and discover your own voice. With a captivating story, unforgettable characters, and an exclusive soundtrack, this game is a must-play.


What we like:
  • Beautiful graphics and realistic scenery
  • Engaging slice-of-life gameplay
  • Unique power to control emotions
  • Realistic portrayal of difficult topics
  • Enjoyable romance options
What could be improved:
  • Predictable plot and lack of impactful choices
  • Episodes feel rushed and underdeveloped
  • Limited character interaction after emotional moments
  • Short gameplay and shallow character relationships

  • narrative
  • episodic
  • supernatural
  • mystery
  • story
  • drama
  • choices
  • adventure
  • romance
  • local
  • puzzle
  • romantic

10

Oxenfree (2016)

View Similar Games
90
Review score
Logo of Oxenfree Screenshot of Oxenfree Screenshot of Oxenfree Screenshot of Oxenfree

Android Linux Mac OS PC Windows Xbox One IOS iPhone

Oxenfree is a supernatural thriller about a group of friends who unwittingly open a ghostly rift. You are Alex, and you’ve just brought your new stepbrother Jonas to an overnight island party gone horribly wrong.


  • supernatural
  • mystery
  • horror
  • narrative
  • military
  • adventure

Not seeing your game?