The Best Supernatural Games - Page 2

Update : The Haunting of Joni Evers added at rank #43.
11

Life is Strange 2 Episode 1 (2018)

View Similar Games
90
Review score
Logo of Life is Strange 2 Episode 1 Screenshot of Life is Strange 2 Episode 1 Screenshot of Life is Strange 2 Episode 1 Screenshot of Life is Strange 2 Episode 1

Playstation 4 Nintendo Switch Linux Mac OS PC Windows Xbox One

After a tragic incident, brothers Sean and Daniel Diaz run away from home. Fearing the police, and dealing with Daniel's new telekinetic power, the boys head to Mexico. Each stop on their journey brings new friends and new challenges.


  • episodic
  • narrative
  • story
  • supernatural
  • choices
  • drama
  • adventure
  • mystery
  • puzzle
  • romance
  • political
  • difficult

12

Life is Strange 2 (2018)

View Similar Games
90
Review score
Logo of Life is Strange 2 Screenshot of Life is Strange 2 Screenshot of Life is Strange 2 Screenshot of Life is Strange 2

Playstation 4 Xbox One PC Windows Mac OS Linux Nintendo Switch

After a tragic incident, brothers Sean and Daniel Diaz run away from home. Fearing the police, and dealing with Daniel's new telekinetic power, the boys head to Mexico. Each stop on their journey brings new friends and new challenges.


  • episodic
  • narrative
  • choices
  • supernatural
  • story
  • drama
  • adventure
  • mystery
  • romance
  • puzzle

13

Life is Strange: True Colors (2021)

View Similar Games
89
Review score
Logo of Life is Strange: True Colors Screenshot of Life is Strange: True Colors Screenshot of Life is Strange: True Colors Screenshot of Life is Strange: True Colors

Playstation 4 IOS iPhone Xbox Series X Xbox One PC Windows stadia Nintendo Switch Playstation 5

Experience a bold new era in the award-winning Life is Strange series with Life is Strange: True Colors. Uncover the shocking secrets behind your brother's death as you navigate through an emotional roller-coaster of an adventure. Harness the power of Empathy to change fate and forge deep relationships with the townsfolk. Make tough decisions, explore the vibrant town of Haven Springs, and discover your own voice. With a captivating story, unforgettable characters, and an exclusive soundtrack, this game is a must-play.


What we like:
  • Beautiful graphics and realistic scenery
  • Engaging slice-of-life gameplay
  • Unique power to control emotions
  • Realistic portrayal of difficult topics
  • Enjoyable romance options
What could be improved:
  • Predictable plot and lack of impactful choices
  • Episodes feel rushed and underdeveloped
  • Limited character interaction after emotional moments
  • Short gameplay and shallow character relationships

  • narrative
  • episodic
  • supernatural
  • mystery
  • story
  • drama
  • choices
  • adventure
  • romance
  • local
  • puzzle
  • romantic
  • difficult

14

Control (2020)

View Similar Games
87
Review score
Logo of Control Screenshot of Control Screenshot of Control Screenshot of Control

Playstation 4 Android Xbox Series X Nintendo Switch Playstation 5 stadia PC Windows Xbox One

Step into the enigmatic world of Control Ultimate Edition, where you wield otherworldly powers and fight through a shape-shifting building. Unravel a dark, gripping narrative and engage in exhilarating combat, using telekinesis and transformable weaponry to restore order against an otherworldly threat. Discover secrets, earn upgrades, and become the master of this reality-bending adventure!


What we like:
  • Gripping narrative
  • Innovative combat mechanics
  • Expansive world with hidden secrets
  • Stunning visuals and environmental effects
  • Included DLC enhances the experience
What could be improved:
  • Saves not transferable between console generations
  • Can be challenging for some

  • supernatural
  • tps
  • story
  • shooter
  • narrative
  • third-person
  • horror
  • sci-fi
  • combat
  • metroidvania
  • action-adventure
  • exploration
  • action
  • boss-fight
  • battle

15

Unavowed (2018)

View Similar Games
87
Review score
Logo of Unavowed Screenshot of Unavowed Screenshot of Unavowed Screenshot of Unavowed

Linux Nintendo Switch Mac OS PC Windows

A demon has possessed you and used your body to tear a swath of bloodshed through New York. You are now free, but life as you knew it is over. Your only path forward is joining the Unavowed - an ancient society dedicated to stopping evil. No matter what the cost.


  • supernatural
  • point-and-click
  • adventure
  • puzzle
  • pixel
  • detective
  • fantasy
  • graphic
  • mystery

16

The Wild Case (2021)

View Similar Games
87
Review score
Logo of The Wild Case Screenshot of The Wild Case Screenshot of The Wild Case Screenshot of The Wild Case

PC Windows Nintendo Switch Android IOS iPhone Mac OS Linux

Embark on a journey to an eerie village shrouded in mystery in The Wild Case. Solve puzzles, negotiate with inhabitants, and uncover supernatural occurrences in this atmospheric adventure. With stunning hand-drawn graphics and haunting sound effects, immerse yourself in an open world that will keep you on edge. Unravel the secrets of the forgotten village if you dare.


What we like:
  • Short but well-rounded gameplay
  • Intriguing mystery with satisfying ending
  • Beautiful hand-drawn artwork
  • Atmospheric music and sound effects
  • Adequate price point
What could be improved:
  • Lack of motivation for replayability
  • Rough English translation
  • Story not frightening for adults

  • detective
  • point-and-click
  • puzzle
  • story
  • hand-drawn
  • adventure
  • atmospheric
  • text
  • supernatural
  • 2d
  • mystery
  • exploration
  • first-person
  • investigation
  • linear

17

Tell Me Why (2020)

View Similar Games
86
Review score
Logo of Tell Me Why Screenshot of Tell Me Why Screenshot of Tell Me Why Screenshot of Tell Me Why

PC Windows Xbox One

Unravel the mysteries of 'Tell Me Why', a narrative adventure game that explores the emotional journey of twins Tyler and Alyson. Your choices shape their lives and their supernatural bond. Dive into an Alaskan setting, solve puzzles, and navigate through their fantasy world. Experience an emotionally intelligent game with beautiful graphics and a well-crafted story.

Buy

What we like:
  • Emotionally rich narrative
  • Beautiful, immersive graphics
  • Impactful player choices
  • Excellent voice acting
  • Respectful LGBTQ+ representation
What could be improved:
  • Similar mechanics to previous games
  • Outdated character models
  • Emotional pacing can be inconsistent

  • narrative
  • supernatural
  • episodic
  • mystery
  • adventure
  • puzzle
  • story
  • drama
  • choices
  • realistic

18

The Darkside Detective (2017)

View Similar Games
86
Review score
Logo of The Darkside Detective Screenshot of The Darkside Detective Screenshot of The Darkside Detective Screenshot of The Darkside Detective

PC Windows Xbox One Playstation 5 Playstation 4 stadia Nintendo Switch Linux Mac OS IOS iPhone

Join Detectives McQueen and Dooley as they solve six different cases full of humour and great references in the town of Twin Lakes. With beautiful retro-style pixel graphics, this is a must play for lovers of cats, coffee and all kinds of videogames!


What we like:
  • Crisp and clean pixel graphics
  • Variety in music
  • Sense of satisfaction when solving a case
  • Humourous atmosphere
  • Great movie references
What could be improved:
  • Cases are straightforward
  • Not super challenging
  • No tries to scare you

  • point-and-click
  • detective
  • supernatural
  • pixel
  • adventure
  • funny
  • retro
  • mystery
  • puzzle
  • comedy

19

MetaPhysical (2023)

View Similar Games
86
Review score
Logo of MetaPhysical Screenshot of MetaPhysical Screenshot of MetaPhysical Screenshot of MetaPhysical

PC Windows

Supernatural phenomena are on the rise. In MetaPhysical you and up to 5 other friends can go on the hunt for eerie creatures to put an end to their sinister activities! Whether it's an ordinary ghost or a demon, your task is to identify the rumbling creature and then finish it off.

Buy

  • dark
  • horror
  • supernatural
  • gothic
  • first-person
  • mythology
  • character
  • fantasy
  • detective
  • demons
  • psychological
  • survival-horror
  • action-adventure
  • shooter
  • customization

20

Life is Strange Remastered Collection (2022)

View Similar Games
85
Review score
Logo of Life is Strange Remastered Collection Screenshot of Life is Strange Remastered Collection Screenshot of Life is Strange Remastered Collection Screenshot of Life is Strange Remastered Collection

Nintendo Switch Playstation 4 stadia PC Windows Xbox One

Experience the BAFTA award-winning story of Life is Strange now beautifully remastered with enhanced visuals and vastly improved animation using mocap technology.


  • episodic
  • narrative
  • supernatural
  • story
  • drama
  • choices
  • adventure
  • mystery
  • romance
  • puzzle

Not seeing your game?