50 Games Like Pony Island

Updated:

Trap, Rusty Lake: Roots, and DERE EVIL .EXE are our top selection to play today.

The latest addition in this selection are Quest room: Hanon released the 19 October 2018 and ranked #49, Path to Mnemosyne released the 25 September 2018 and ranked #43, PUSS! released the 2 August 2018 and ranked #50.

50 Games like Pony Island daily generated comparing over 40 000 video games across all platforms.
This suggestion collection includes horror puzzle games for Android, IOS (iPhone / iPad), Win Mobile, PS4 (Playstation 4), Switch, PC Windows, Mac OS and Linux. The order in this selection is not absolute, but the best games tends to be up in the list.

Logo of the video game Pony Island

No internet connection required * DESIGN beautiful accessories and castles * MEET cute ponies and their animal friends * DISCOVER beautiful and cute ponies of all sizes and shapes * 2 FREE mini games to enjoy! Make your visitors happy - show them your beautiful ponies and decorated fairytale castle. Populate it with ponies and their friends, and meet all kinds of cute animals that live in the sky kingdom.

1# Trap - 2018

Review88Score

After receiving a disturbing letter from his brother, our protagonist decides to go looking for him at the hotel Beryl. He will soon discover the strangeness of the places, the objects, the paintings, the shadows and the terrifying models moving, speaking, living of their own will.

Trap similarities with Pony Island:

2# Rusty Lake: Roots - 2016

Review93Score

Experience the beginning and end of characters' lives and build your own family tree! Rusty Lake: Roots is the second premium point-and-click adventure by the creators of the Cube Escape series and Rusty Lake Hotel.

Rusty Lake: Roots similarities with Pony Island:

5# the static speaks my name - 2015

Review78Score

A dark/sad/weird/funny first person exploration game. You play a man on his last night alive as he obsesses over a mysterious painting. More of a story game in that it emphasizes mood and character over gameplay. Takes ten minutes to play and has "next-gen" features like a shrimp tank.

the static speaks my name similarities with Pony Island:

10# Welcome to the Game - 2016

ReviewNDScore

Welcome to the Game is a creepy horror/puzzle game that takes you into the world of the Deep Web. Explore the Deep Web with the sole purpose of trying to find a Red Room, an online service / website that allows you to see and participate in interactive torture and murder.

Welcome to the Game similarities with Pony Island:

11# Hellblade: Senua's Sacrifice - 2017

Review84Score

From the makers of Heavenly Sword, Enslaved: Odyssey to the West, and DmC: Devil May Cry, comes a warrior’s brutal journey into myth and madness. Set in the Viking age, a broken Celtic warrior embarks on a haunting vision quest into Viking Hell to fight for the soul of her dead lover.

Hellblade: Senua's Sacrifice similarities with Pony Island:

17# DISTRAINT - 2015

Review81Score

In order to secure a partnership in a famous company, Price seizes the property of an elderly woman. The gameplay is simple but effective: You move left and right and solve puzzles to progress through the atmospheric story.

DISTRAINT similarities with Pony Island:

19# Detention - 2017

Review89Score

Detention is a atmospheric horror game set in 1960s Taiwan under martial law. Incorporated religious elements based in Taiwanese/Chinese culture and mythology, the game provided players with unique graphics and gaming experience.

Detention similarities with Pony Island:

20# 8-BIT WATERSLIDE - 2015

Review79Score

Take control of a screaming coward, TIPLER as he hurtles along this awesome pixel death slide. "If you love retro graphics and have a big sense of humor, then 8-BIT WATERSLIDE is the perfect little gem for you!" "Playing convulsed with laughter can be considered a good gaming experience" - sspai

8-BIT WATERSLIDE similarities with Pony Island:

21# Selma and the Wisp - 2016

ReviewNDScore

Selma and the Wisp is an astonishing platform game with a particularly eerie feel to it. Densely packed with logical puzzles and unexpected obstacles, the game incorporates innovative gameplay, low-poly models and an spectacular animations.

Selma and the Wisp similarities with Pony Island:

22# Reflection of Mine - 2017

ReviewNDScore

Reflection of Mine is a dark puzzle video game about the dissociative identity disorder. The entire game takes place in the broken mind of Lilly Witchgan and the goal is to discover who is real – Lilly herself or one of her many personalities. The plot will tell us about her many minds and how are they fighting each other.

Reflection of Mine similarities with Pony Island:

23# Welcome to the Game II - 2017

ReviewNDScore
Screenshot of the video game Welcome to the Game II
Screenshot of the video game Welcome to the Game II
Screenshot of the video game Welcome to the Game II

Welcome to the Game II is an atmospheric horror / strategy / puzzle game that takes you into the world of the deep web in search of the shadow web. Play as an investigative reporter trying to solve a case of a mysterious woman broadcasting for help as masked men are on the hunt to kill her.

Welcome to the Game II similarities with Pony Island:

12 sept 2018 - New comment system! Drop us a line