The Best Supernatural Games - Page 2

Update : The Unholy Priest added at rank #1.
11

Paranormal Night Shift (2025)

View Similar Games
ND
Review score
Logo of Paranormal Night Shift Screenshot of Paranormal Night Shift Screenshot of Paranormal Night Shift Screenshot of Paranormal Night Shift

PC Windows

Paranormal Night Shift is an observation and spot the anomaly game set in a haunted house in the 1980s.

Buy

  • horror
  • 1980s
  • psychological
  • supernatural
  • gore
  • fiction
  • immersive
  • mystery
  • hidden-object
  • interactive
  • realistic
  • puzzle
  • demons
  • simulation
  • survival-horror

12

The Haunting of Joni Evers (2025)

View Similar Games
ND
Review score
Logo of The Haunting of Joni Evers Screenshot of The Haunting of Joni Evers Screenshot of The Haunting of Joni Evers Screenshot of The Haunting of Joni Evers

PC Windows Mac OS

The Haunting of Joni Evers is an emotional tale of a broken family from small-town Oklahoma, driven apart by a malevolent haunting. Uncover the mysteries of Joni’s family and the Cunningham House, digging through memories, facing the family’s past to break the curse.

Buy

  • walking-simulator
  • supernatural
  • short
  • emotional
  • narration
  • fiction
  • visual-novel
  • horror
  • psychological
  • mystery
  • drama
  • story
  • atmospheric
  • interactive
  • exploration

13

Unpossess: Exorcism Simulator (2025)

View Similar Games
75
Review score
Logo of Unpossess: Exorcism Simulator Screenshot of Unpossess: Exorcism Simulator Screenshot of Unpossess: Exorcism Simulator Screenshot of Unpossess: Exorcism Simulator

early access PC Windows Android

Unpossess is a 1-4 co-op exorcism simulator game set in the early 1900s. Players take on the role of exorcists responsible for addressing cases of human possession.


  • horror
  • dark
  • supernatural
  • cooperative
  • demons
  • psychological
  • thriller
  • survival-horror
  • realistic
  • simulation
  • horror-adventure
  • immersive
  • fantasy
  • multiplayer

14

Hell Dive (2025)

View Similar Games
ND
Review score
Logo of Hell Dive Screenshot of Hell Dive Screenshot of Hell Dive Screenshot of Hell Dive

PC Windows

A first-person horror game where you play as Daniel, a Maritime Operative trapped alone aboard a submarine. Sent to investigate an abandoned deep-sea colony, you uncover dark secrets as terrifying horrors await in its depths.

Buy

  • submarine
  • psychological
  • immersive
  • supernatural
  • walking-simulator
  • resource-management
  • survival-horror
  • horror
  • multiple-endings
  • dark
  • atmospheric
  • story
  • exploration
  • sci-fi
  • mystery

15

Polygon of Reality (2024)

View Similar Games
ND
Review score
Logo of Polygon of Reality Screenshot of Polygon of Reality Screenshot of Polygon of Reality Screenshot of Polygon of Reality

PC Windows

"Polygon of Reality" is a horror game in which you will have to unravel the mysteries of other dimensions and a research complex. Descend into the complex buried in the ground, uncover the mysteries of what happened, meet with forgotten fears and unknown creatures.

Buy

  • nonlinear
  • survival-horror
  • multiple-endings
  • supernatural
  • dark
  • horror
  • atmospheric
  • investigation
  • futuristic
  • sci-fi
  • mystery
  • violent
  • story
  • exploration
  • realistic

16

The Supernatural Power Troll (2024)

View Similar Games
ND
Review score
Logo of The Supernatural Power Troll Screenshot of The Supernatural Power Troll Screenshot of The Supernatural Power Troll Screenshot of The Supernatural Power Troll

PC Windows Linux Mac OS

Step into the shoes of a mischievous Power Troll, gifting humans with powers they’re definitely not ready for! Watch the chaos unfold as each NPC reacts in bizarre and unpredictable ways. Each encounter is a new disaster waiting to happen—how much chaos can one troll create?

Buy

  • platform
  • 2d
  • humor
  • supernatural
  • dark
  • superhero
  • logic
  • third-person
  • puzzle
  • cartoony
  • fantasy
  • cute
  • funny
  • pixel
  • colourful

17

Happy Home: Prologue (2024)

View Similar Games
ND
Review score
Logo of Happy Home: Prologue Screenshot of Happy Home: Prologue Screenshot of Happy Home: Prologue Screenshot of Happy Home: Prologue

PC Windows

Explore the beginning of a new horrifying story in this mixture of a text-based and a 2D game. Emily's world is about to turn upside down, maybe in more ways than anyone is able to realize yet.

Buy

  • psychological
  • hand-drawn
  • horror
  • choices
  • supernatural
  • emotional
  • visual-novel
  • text
  • scroller
  • stylized
  • dark
  • investigation
  • atmospheric
  • 2d

18

The Dark Queen of Mortholme (2024)

View Similar Games
ND
Review score
Logo of The Dark Queen of Mortholme Screenshot of The Dark Queen of Mortholme Screenshot of The Dark Queen of Mortholme Screenshot of The Dark Queen of Mortholme

j PC Windows

You are the final boss, the Dark Queen of Mortholme, unrivaled in power. A hero invades and is easily crushed. Yet, they keep returning. A short-form indie game about an unusual bond, perspectives, and the beauty of change.

Buy

  • lgbtq
  • otome
  • romance
  • souls
  • atmospheric
  • supernatural
  • emotional
  • choices
  • psychological
  • 2d
  • visual-novel
  • drama
  • action-adventure
  • story
  • linear

19

A Winter Haunting (2024)

View Similar Games
ND
Review score
Logo of A Winter Haunting Screenshot of A Winter Haunting Screenshot of A Winter Haunting Screenshot of A Winter Haunting

Mac OS PC Windows

Everlyn Sterling, a young woman tasked by her grandmother to take care of a historic mansion, finds herself entangled in a mystery involving supernatural forces. Join her in this point-and-click style game to uncover the secrets behind this landmark!

Buy

  • point-and-click
  • hidden-object
  • detective
  • psychological
  • investigation
  • multiple-endings
  • supernatural
  • choices
  • logic
  • exploration
  • minimalist
  • horror
  • mystery
  • 2d
  • story

20

Cartier 06 (2024)

View Similar Games
ND
Review score
Logo of Cartier 06 Screenshot of Cartier 06 Screenshot of Cartier 06 Screenshot of Cartier 06

PC Windows

After a long day at work, all you want is to relax on the couch—but the night has other plans. Step into the shoes of a Romanian engineer in the mid-2000s and survive a harrowing night as something hunts you in the shadows.

Buy

  • immersive
  • thriller
  • supernatural
  • horror
  • first-person
  • walking-simulator
  • fiction
  • mystery
  • narration
  • conversation
  • fps
  • realistic
  • investigation
  • atmospheric
  • interactive

Not seeing your game?