50 Games Like When The Night Comes

Update, : Mythos Ever After: A Cthulhu Dating Sim RX added at ranked #23.

When The Night Comes is a queer, narrative-driven, supernatural visual novel.

1

Scarlet Hollow (2021)

View Similar Games
ND
Review score
>

Mac OS PC Windows

Scarlet Hollow is a horror-mystery game with sharp writing, dark humor, and hand-drawn art from award-winning graphic novelist Abby Howard.

Buy

Scarlet Hollow similarities with When The Night Comes
  • fiction 100
  • multiple-endings 100
  • visual-novel 90
  • interactive 90
  • humor 90
  • supernatural 70
  • lgbtq 70
  • dark 60
  • choices 50
  • romance 50
  • horror 50

2

Purrfect Apawcalypse: Patches' Infurno (2021)

View Similar Games
ND
Review score
>

PC Windows Mac OS

Patches is dragged to school for the first ever cat-and-dog school day! All he needs to do is get this damn collar off and wreck some havoc! Will he prove cats and dogs can get along, or will he make this the Purrfect Apawcalypse?

Buy

Purrfect Apawcalypse: Patches' Infurno similarities with When The Night Comes
  • humor 100
  • multiple-endings 100
  • fiction 90
  • lgbtq 90
  • horror 90
  • visual-novel 80
  • dating-sim 80
  • magic 70
  • choices 50
  • dark 50

3

Angel Wings (2021)

View Similar Games
ND
Review score
>

PC Windows

Upon answering a mysterious phone call, you awaken in an unfamiliar place filled with new faces… Through intricate relationships and thoughtful introspection, will you be able to unravel the reason you are here?

Buy

Angel Wings similarities with When The Night Comes
  • visual-novel 100
  • dating-sim 100
  • multiple-endings 100
  • humor 100
  • interactive 90
  • fiction 70
  • romance 70
  • choices 50
  • dark 50
  • lgbtq 50

4

Purrfect Apawcalypse: Love at Furst Bite (2021)

View Similar Games
ND
Review score
>

PC Windows Mac OS

Olive is trapped in school in the midst of the apocalypse! With demons slaughtering every dog in sight there's only so many left to spend time with! Will their special someone be Brownie the snack-loving corgi, Sparky the sporty husky or Patches the dalmatian bookworm? You decide!

Buy

Purrfect Apawcalypse: Love at Furst Bite similarities with When The Night Comes
  • fiction 100
  • visual-novel 90
  • dating-sim 90
  • multiple-endings 90
  • lgbtq 90
  • magic 70
  • choices 50
  • dark 50
  • supernatural 50

5

Jester King (2021)

View Similar Games
ND
Review score
>

Linux Mac OS PC Windows

You are a jester who wakes up next to the king's lifeless body. A curse has fallen upon the kingdom, and each of your friends is a suspect. What is more important - escaping or discovering the truth?

Buy

Jester King similarities with When The Night Comes
  • interactive 100
  • fiction 100
  • dating-sim 90
  • lgbtq 90
  • visual-novel 80
  • multiple-endings 80
  • romance 80
  • choices 50
  • dark 40

6

Monstrous Lovers (2021)

View Similar Games
ND
Review score
>

PC Windows Mac OS Linux

In this Boys' Love visual novel about dating monsters, you play as Christopher Wells, a young office worker who moves to a town full of supernatural creatures in hopes of getting to make a real difference.

Buy

Monstrous Lovers similarities with When The Night Comes
  • lgbtq 100
  • visual-novel 100
  • romance 100
  • choices 70
  • multiple-endings 70
  • fiction 60
  • supernatural 60
  • interactive 60

7

Follow Your Heart (2021)

View Similar Games
ND
Review score
>

PC Windows

Follow Your Heart is an addicting game in which you have to solve puzzles with Lovely Girls.The game is perfect for relaxing.

Buy

Follow Your Heart similarities with When The Night Comes
  • romance 100
  • humor 100
  • dating-sim 90
  • visual-novel 70
  • fiction 70
  • choices 70
  • multiple-endings 70
  • dark 50

8

Ascension: Transition and Silver (2021)

View Similar Games
ND
Review score
>

PC Windows

Ascension is a visual novel following three lost souls as they venture into The Zone - a dangerous and alien world. Follow the abrasive Doctor, the shy Scholar and sardonic Escort on their journey - though none of them will come out unscathed.

Buy

Ascension: Transition and Silver similarities with When The Night Comes
  • lgbtq 100
  • visual-novel 90
  • multiple-endings 90
  • romance 90
  • fiction 80
  • choices 80
  • interactive 80
  • horror 50

9

A Pinch of Magic (2021)

View Similar Games
ND
Review score
>

PC Windows

Save your grandparent's failing café/magic shop from bankruptcy and possibly fall in love!

Buy

A Pinch of Magic similarities with When The Night Comes
  • lgbtq 100
  • fantasy 100
  • visual-novel 90
  • dating-sim 90
  • choices 80
  • magic 70
  • romance 60
  • multiple-endings 50

10

Love Decision (2021)

View Similar Games
ND
Review score
>

PC Windows Linux

Kingdoms rise and fall. Everyone has their goals.

Buy

Love Decision similarities with When The Night Comes
  • visual-novel 100
  • choices 100
  • romance 100
  • dating-sim 80
  • fiction 70
  • fantasy 70
  • interactive 70
  • multiple-endings 60