50 Games Like New York Mysteries: Secrets of the Mafia

Updated:

Dead Reckoning: Silvermoon Isle, League of Light: Wicked Harvest, and Grim Legends are our top selection to play today.

The latest addition in this selection are Cadenza: The Kiss of Death released the 15 December 2017 and ranked #49, Riddles of Fate: Into Oblivion released the 13 June 2017 and ranked #6, The Agency of Anomalies: The Last Performance released the 12 June 2017 and ranked #25.

50 Games like New York Mysteries: Secrets of the Mafia daily generated comparing over 40 000 video games across all platforms.
This suggestion collection includes casual puzzle adventure games for Android, Win Mobile, PS4 (Playstation 4), Xbox One, PC Windows, Mac OS, Linux and 3DS. The order in this selection is not absolute, but the best games tends to be up in the list.

Logo of the video game New York Mysteries: Secrets of the Mafia

New York, 1955. It's become dangerous in the city. The mafia is trying to seize power. But recently, a new force appeared. A far more terrible force. Over the last few days, five mafia bosses have disappeared in mysterious circumstances. A strange liquid and a butterfly were found at the scenes of the disappearances. But this isn't what scared the citizens... Children started to disappear in the city. All of them drew exactly the same butterflies before they disappeared. This forced detectives and journalists alike to start their investigations.

3# Grim Legends - 2017

Review86Score

Sylvia and her master, Solomon, embark on an adventure that will lead them into the city of Lichtenheim, where they will face the thief whose identity will come as no less a shock than the actual disappearance of the artifact. The heroin and her mentor will need to put on their detective hats and face not only the evil forces within the gothic walls of the grim city, but also dark secrets from the past.

Grim Legends similarities with New York Mysteries: Secrets of the Mafia:

4# Hidden Expedition: The Crown of Solomon - 2015

Review92Score

The expedition continues... Track down the fragments of King Solomon's crown and foil a madman's plot in this exciting follow-up to the bestselling series! You've stopped the Robideaux family from stealing the Hope Diamond and using its shards for their own twisted ends. But before Robideaux's cargo can make it safely back to the museum where it belongs, a criminal has stolen a valuable artifact. It's a piece of King Solomon's crown, long broken apart, its fragments scattered across the globe. Can you pick up the pieces in time?

Hidden Expedition: The Crown of Solomon similarities with New York Mysteries: Secrets of the Mafia:

5# Dark Parables: Jack and the Sky Kingdom - 2015

Review93Score

The legendary Sky Kingdom suddenly appears and a destructive barrage is unleashed upon an unsuspecting town. Play as the Fairytale Detective and embark on an investigation to rescue the townspeople. In this quest, you will meet Jack - an infamous treasure hunter who shares a secret past with the Kingdom - and discover the tragic history behind the chaos. This is a special Collector's Edition release full of exclusive extras you won’t find in the standard version. As a bonus, Collector's Edition purchases count toward three stamps on your Monthly Game Club Punch Card! The Collector’s Edition includes:

Dark Parables: Jack and the Sky Kingdom similarities with New York Mysteries: Secrets of the Mafia:

10# Nevertales: The Beauty Within - 2015

Review94Score

Just when you were finally done with work for the day, a stranger comes knocking loudly at your door. When you answer there's no one... no one except a helpless baby abandoned on your doorstep. You follow after the stranger, hoping to find some answers but are drawn into a mystery that beckons you into a castle-like mansion. Who does the baby belong to? Why were you chosen? The answers will surprise you in Nevertales: The Beauty Within, a page-turning Hidden Object Puzzle Adventure game! This is a special Collector's Edition release full of exclusive extras you won’t find in the standard version. As a bonus, Collector's Edition purchases count toward three stamps on your Monthly Game Club Punch Card! The Collector’s Edition includes:

Nevertales: The Beauty Within similarities with New York Mysteries: Secrets of the Mafia:

11# Dead Reckoning: Brassfield Manor - 2015

Review88Score

From Eipix Entertainment, makers of Dead Reckoning: Silvermoon Isle and the Final Cut series! On the eve of his annual murder mystery party, wealthy businessman Reginald Greer is found dead at his home. You've been called to Brassfield Manor to solve the case… but it won't be easy. There are plenty of clues and suspects to keep you guessing who killed Reginald Greer. Was it his spoiled daughter? His jealous son? His disgruntled business partner? It could be any one of the guests who arrived for a game... and stayed for a murder. Use a unique deduction feature to question characters and examine evidence in this intriguing Hidden Object Puzzle Adventure whodunit game!

Dead Reckoning: Brassfield Manor similarities with New York Mysteries: Secrets of the Mafia:

19# Mayan Prophecies: Ship of Spirits - 2017

Review93Score

Explore the vastness of a ship lost in time, what mysteries will you uncover amidst its Mayan idols, menacing sea creatures, and exotic treasures? Find out in this exciting new Hidden Object Puzzle Adventure game on the open seas!

Mayan Prophecies: Ship of Spirits similarities with New York Mysteries: Secrets of the Mafia:

23# GRAVEN The Purple Moon Prophecy - 2015

Review93Score

An invitation to research ancient menhirs sends you to Brittany to find these magnificent standing stones. But you quickly discover there is far more at stake than groundbreaking research. There is a prophecy, one that foretells chaos and evil being unleashed upon the world on the night when a comet hides behind the moon and turns the sky purple. Tonight is that night. Can you race against the clock to save not only yourself, but the fate of two worlds?

GRAVEN The Purple Moon Prophecy similarities with New York Mysteries: Secrets of the Mafia:

24# Spirit of Revenge: Cursed Castle - 2015

Review92Score

From Vendel Games, creators of Love Chronicles, comes a haunting new mystery series! Despite rumors that their Gothic castle is cursed, the Flatsburys returned to live there. Now Lord Flatsbury and his son have vanished, and only little Jessie saw what happened. Can you win the girl's trust and solve the mystery that spooked her into silence? Find out in this thrilling Hidden Object Puzzle Adventure game! Just be sure to watch your step - no one ever leaves this castle alive…

Spirit of Revenge: Cursed Castle similarities with New York Mysteries: Secrets of the Mafia:

12 sept 2018 - New comment system! Drop us a line