The Best Horror storytelling Games for Playstation 5 - Page 3

Update : Vlad Circus: Curse of Asmodeus added at rank #33.
Here are our 10 Best Horror storytelling Games for Playstation 5, position 21 to 30:
21

Beyond Hanwell (2024)

View Similar Games
76
Review score
Logo of Beyond Hanwell Screenshot of Beyond Hanwell Screenshot of Beyond Hanwell Screenshot of Beyond Hanwell

Xbox One Playstation 5 PC Windows

Explore Westminster, London on a journey to the ruins of Hanwell. Fight with whatever you can find or use the environment to defend yourself against an ever increasing scourge of Anomalies.


  • horror
  • immersive
  • psychological
  • survival-horror
  • first-person
  • dark
  • open-world
  • atmospheric
  • shooter
  • post-apocalyptic
  • realistic
  • story
  • gore
  • fps
  • combat

22

Remorse: The List (2022)

View Similar Games
75
Review score
Logo of Remorse: The List Screenshot of Remorse: The List Screenshot of Remorse: The List Screenshot of Remorse: The List

Playstation 5 Xbox Series X Nintendo Switch Xbox One Playstation 4 PC Windows

Remorse: The List is a classic survival horror game where the player must figure out what is happening in the little hungarian town of Hidegpuszta, and your only clue is a list that doesn't make much sense. Exploring will be the key to unveiling its secrets and get out of there alive.


  • survival-horror
  • horror
  • first-person
  • gore
  • shooter
  • psychological
  • violent
  • open-world
  • fps
  • dark
  • action-adventure
  • exploration
  • atmospheric
  • 3d
  • story

23

Teacup (2020)

View Similar Games
96
Review score
Logo of Teacup Screenshot of Teacup Screenshot of Teacup Screenshot of Teacup

Xbox Series X Playstation 5 Nintendo Switch Playstation 4 Xbox One PC Windows

Teacup is a short and wholesome narrative adventure game with a focus on exploration and non-linear progression. You play as the titular Teacup, a shy and introverted young frog who loves drinking tea and reading. The day before she is to host a tea party at her house, she realizes she is completely out of tea, and thus must venture into the woods around her to find the herbs she needs to restock her pantry. During your adventure you will meet the charming inhabitants of the forest. Some are talkative, some are grumpy, but all of them will lend you an ear on your adventure. Explore this gorgeous watercolor world filled with friendly animals, playful minigames, puzzles, and beautiful, calming wilderness.


  • nonlinear
  • scroller
  • cute
  • exploration
  • adventure
  • narrative
  • relaxing
  • horror
  • family-friendly
  • colourful
  • coffee
  • story
  • non-linear
  • funny
  • 2d

24

Control: AWE (2020)

View Similar Games
75
Review score
Logo of Control: AWE Screenshot of Control: AWE Screenshot of Control: AWE Screenshot of Control: AWE

Playstation 4 Xbox One PC Windows Playstation 5 Xbox Series X/s

Winner of over 80 awards, Control is a visually stunning third-person action-adventure that will keep you on the edge of your seat.


  • supernatural
  • horror
  • story
  • narrative
  • tps
  • boss-fight
  • third-person
  • sci-fi
  • shooter
  • action-adventure
  • combat
  • action
  • fight
  • puzzle

25

Control (2020)

View Similar Games
87
Review score
Logo of Control Screenshot of Control Screenshot of Control Screenshot of Control

Playstation 4 Xbox One PC Windows stadia Playstation 5 Nintendo Switch Xbox Series X Android

Step into the enigmatic world of Control Ultimate Edition, where you wield otherworldly powers and fight through a shape-shifting building. Unravel a dark, gripping narrative and engage in exhilarating combat, using telekinesis and transformable weaponry to restore order against an otherworldly threat. Discover secrets, earn upgrades, and become the master of this reality-bending adventure!

Buy

What we like:
  • Gripping narrative
  • Innovative combat mechanics
  • Expansive world with hidden secrets
  • Stunning visuals and environmental effects
  • Included DLC enhances the experience
What could be improved:
  • Saves not transferable between console generations
  • Can be challenging for some

  • supernatural
  • story
  • tps
  • shooter
  • third-person
  • metroidvania
  • action-adventure
  • boss-fight
  • real-time
  • narrative
  • horror
  • sci-fi
  • action
  • exploration
  • combat

26

Creepy Tale: Ingrid Penance (2023)

View Similar Games
82
Review score
Logo of Creepy Tale: Ingrid Penance Screenshot of Creepy Tale: Ingrid Penance Screenshot of Creepy Tale: Ingrid Penance Screenshot of Creepy Tale: Ingrid Penance

Playstation 5 Playstation 4 Xbox One Xbox Series X PC Windows Nintendo Switch

As punishment for her transgressions, Ingrid is sent to hell. As she struggles through the darkness that hungers to consume her heart, she makes her way toward redemption. Her fate is in your hands.


  • escape
  • room
  • horror
  • dark
  • narration
  • supernatural
  • puzzle
  • point-and-click
  • drama
  • psychological
  • hand-drawn
  • scroller
  • atmospheric
  • mystery
  • story

27

Gray Dawn (2018)

View Similar Games
83
Review score
Logo of Gray Dawn Screenshot of Gray Dawn Screenshot of Gray Dawn Screenshot of Gray Dawn

l j Xbox Series X PC Windows Android Xbox One Playstation 4 Playstation 5

You will be entangled in a terrifying adventure of a priest on a quest to prove his innocence. Guilty or not, you find yourself trapped in the middle of strange events involving a demonic possession and divine apparitions. Each time you remember the boy or hear about being accused of murder, you go into a trance fueled by fear. These moments of madness depict gore, repulsion towards God, and sometimes even the voice of the devil himself trying to convince you of things that may or may not be lies...Gray Dawn takes place around the year 1920, in a remote village in England. Throughout the game, you will often be transported to the beautiful world of Romania, which is inspired by the mysticism of Eastern Europe.


  • horror
  • thriller
  • lovecraftian
  • psychological
  • gore
  • walking-simulator
  • violent
  • story
  • adventure
  • religiously
  • supernatural
  • atmospheric
  • surreal
  • first-person

28

Discolored 2 (2025)

View Similar Games
ND
Review score
Logo of Discolored 2 Screenshot of Discolored 2 Screenshot of Discolored 2 Screenshot of Discolored 2

j Playstation 5 Nintendo Switch PC Windows

All the colors have gone missing from the world. While on a mission to bring them back you discover you are being hunted by those who would see the colors banished. Your only hope is a woman in red who may be holding the key to preventing the world from becoming discolored.


  • horror
  • lore
  • surreal
  • vampire
  • psychological
  • thriller
  • puzzle
  • first-person
  • exploration
  • action-adventure
  • mystery
  • story
  • survival-horror
  • difficult
  • survival

29

Puppet House (2024)

View Similar Games
ND
Review score
Logo of Puppet House Screenshot of Puppet House Screenshot of Puppet House Screenshot of Puppet House

j PC Windows Playstation 5 Xbox Series X Xbox One

Puppet House is a puzzle-adventure horror with escape room elements. A freak ritual creates a killer puppet, murdering anyone who enters the ventriloquist’s mansion. Detective Rick, seeking missing locals, will soon face his greatest horror.


  • horror
  • cinematic
  • narration
  • psychological
  • psychedelic
  • mystery
  • dark
  • action-adventure
  • survival
  • 3d
  • detective
  • story
  • thriller
  • atmospheric
  • exploration

30

Night Book (2021)

View Similar Games
65
Review score
Logo of Night Book Screenshot of Night Book Screenshot of Night Book Screenshot of Night Book

IOS iPhone IOS iPhone (IOS iPhone) l Nintendo Switch PC Windows Playstation 4 Playstation 5 Xbox One Xbox Series X Mac OS

Tricked into reading an ancient book, Loralyn summons a demon into her home. Night Book is an interactive occult thriller movie, created in lockdown, from the publishers of The Complex, Five Dates and Maid of Sker.


  • thriller
  • horror
  • supernatural
  • occult
  • narrative
  • top-notch
  • multiple-endings
  • psychological
  • story
  • grand
  • comedy

Not seeing your game?