The Best Horror storytelling Games for Playstation 5 - Page 2

Update : Death Relives added at rank #39.
11

Immortality (2022)

View Similar Games
86
Review score
Logo of Immortality Screenshot of Immortality Screenshot of Immortality Screenshot of Immortality

Android IOS iPhone PC Windows Xbox Series X Mac OS Playstation 5 Xbox One m IOS iPhone (IOS iPhone) j

Delve into the enigmatic world of IMMORTALITY, where you piece together Marissa Marcel's vanished career through lost film footage. Discover the secrets behind her unreleased movies and uncover a narrative woven with Hollywood's allure and darkness. Your curiosity unlocks a story buried in time, promising a thrilling journey through cinema history.


What we like:
  • Innovative narrative structure that immerses you in detective work
  • Stellar acting enhances the story's authenticity
  • Unique match cut mechanic offers a novel way to navigate the plot
  • Impressive production quality recreates distinct filmmaking eras
  • Rich historical setting amplifies the narrative depth
What could be improved:
  • Free-form structure may confuse new players
  • Vast amount of footage can overwhelm

  • fmv
  • interactive
  • noir
  • lgbtq
  • hidden-object
  • choices
  • emotional
  • immersive
  • detective
  • point-and-click
  • film
  • horror
  • fiction
  • story
  • drama

12

A Plague Tale: Innocence (2019)

View Similar Games
90
Review score
Logo of A Plague Tale: Innocence Screenshot of A Plague Tale: Innocence Screenshot of A Plague Tale: Innocence Screenshot of A Plague Tale: Innocence

Playstation 4 Playstation 5 Xbox Series X PC Windows Xbox One

Follow the grim tale of young Amicia and her little brother Hugo, in a heartrending journey through the darkest hours of history.

Buy

  • stealth
  • medieval
  • story
  • dark
  • atmospheric
  • survival
  • third-person
  • adventure
  • horror
  • emotional
  • historical
  • action-adventure
  • violent

13

Amanda the Adventurer (2022)

View Similar Games
83
Review score
Logo of Amanda the Adventurer Screenshot of Amanda the Adventurer Screenshot of Amanda the Adventurer Screenshot of Amanda the Adventurer

Nintendo Switch IOS iPhone (IOS iPhone) j PC Windows Playstation 5 Playstation 4 Xbox Series X Xbox One Android

Join Amanda and her pal Wooly on a series of adventures as they explore and learn about our wonderful world! With several NEW play-along, laugh-along, learn-along episodes there's always fun to be had! Just make sure to do everything Amanda says or she might get angry.


  • horror
  • 1990s
  • puzzle
  • psychological
  • mystery
  • first-person
  • story
  • interactive
  • old-school
  • fiction
  • choices
  • point-and-click
  • atmospheric
  • live-action

14

CASE 2: Animatronics Survival (2018)

View Similar Games
93
Review score
Logo of CASE 2: Animatronics Survival Screenshot of CASE 2: Animatronics Survival Screenshot of CASE 2: Animatronics Survival Screenshot of CASE 2: Animatronics Survival

Playstation 5 Nintendo Switch PC Windows Xbox One

CASE 2: Animatronics Survival is a horror game that is available in two modes. Online mode lets one or more players take on the role of animatronics, ready to crush everyone and everything. The other three are survivors. How did this happen? You’ll have to find out!


  • horror
  • first-person
  • pvp
  • psychological
  • robots
  • supernatural
  • action-adventure
  • stealth
  • multiplayer
  • fps
  • survival-horror
  • story
  • atmospheric
  • mmo
  • amusement

15

Homebody (2023)

View Similar Games
76
Review score
Logo of Homebody Screenshot of Homebody Screenshot of Homebody Screenshot of Homebody

Nintendo Switch Xbox Series X Playstation 5 Playstation 4 PC Windows dos Xbox One

Homebody is a survival horror puzzle game about a group of friends haunted by memories of the past and hunted by a relentless killer. Move on or die trying.


  • horror
  • survival-horror
  • retro-but-modern
  • choices
  • retro
  • point-and-click
  • psychological
  • puzzle
  • noir
  • memes
  • story
  • fiction
  • third-person
  • old-school
  • atmospheric

16

Daydream: Forgotten Sorrow (2023)

View Similar Games
66
Review score
Logo of Daydream: Forgotten Sorrow Screenshot of Daydream: Forgotten Sorrow Screenshot of Daydream: Forgotten Sorrow Screenshot of Daydream: Forgotten Sorrow

PC Windows j Playstation 5 Playstation 4 Xbox Series X Xbox One Nintendo Switch

In this puzzle platformer, you will embark on a touching journey through the surreal world of a person's mind as a young Griffin and his faithful bear, Birly. Overcome challenges, avoid traps and defeat enemies to help the man find peace.


  • platform
  • puzzle
  • emotional
  • surreal
  • horror
  • 2.5d
  • story
  • atmospheric
  • cute
  • psychological
  • dark
  • adventure
  • action-adventure
  • colourful
  • fantasy

17

Control (2020)

View Similar Games
87
Review score
Logo of Control Screenshot of Control Screenshot of Control Screenshot of Control

Playstation 4 Android Xbox Series X Nintendo Switch Playstation 5 stadia PC Windows Xbox One

Step into the enigmatic world of Control Ultimate Edition, where you wield otherworldly powers and fight through a shape-shifting building. Unravel a dark, gripping narrative and engage in exhilarating combat, using telekinesis and transformable weaponry to restore order against an otherworldly threat. Discover secrets, earn upgrades, and become the master of this reality-bending adventure!

Buy

What we like:
  • Gripping narrative
  • Innovative combat mechanics
  • Expansive world with hidden secrets
  • Stunning visuals and environmental effects
  • Included DLC enhances the experience
What could be improved:
  • Saves not transferable between console generations
  • Can be challenging for some

  • supernatural
  • tps
  • story
  • shooter
  • narrative
  • third-person
  • horror
  • sci-fi
  • combat
  • metroidvania
  • action-adventure
  • exploration
  • action
  • boss-fight
  • battle

18

Control: AWE (2020)

View Similar Games
75
Review score
Logo of Control: AWE Screenshot of Control: AWE Screenshot of Control: AWE Screenshot of Control: AWE

Playstation 4 Xbox One PC Windows Playstation 5 Xbox Series X/s

Winner of over 80 awards, Control is a visually stunning third-person action-adventure that will keep you on the edge of your seat.


  • supernatural
  • horror
  • story
  • narrative
  • tps
  • boss-fight
  • third-person
  • sci-fi
  • shooter
  • action-adventure
  • combat
  • action
  • fight
  • puzzle

19

Remorse: The List (2022)

View Similar Games
75
Review score
Logo of Remorse: The List Screenshot of Remorse: The List Screenshot of Remorse: The List Screenshot of Remorse: The List

Playstation 5 Xbox Series X Nintendo Switch Xbox One Playstation 4 PC Windows

Remorse: The List is a classic survival horror game where the player must figure out what is happening in the little hungarian town of Hidegpuszta, and your only clue is a list that doesn't make much sense. Exploring will be the key to unveiling its secrets and get out of there alive.


  • survival-horror
  • horror
  • first-person
  • gore
  • shooter
  • psychological
  • violent
  • open-world
  • fps
  • dark
  • action-adventure
  • exploration
  • atmospheric
  • 3d
  • story

20

Teacup (2020)

View Similar Games
96
Review score
Logo of Teacup Screenshot of Teacup Screenshot of Teacup Screenshot of Teacup

Xbox Series X Playstation 5 Nintendo Switch Playstation 4 Xbox One PC Windows

Teacup is a short and wholesome narrative adventure game with a focus on exploration and non-linear progression. You play as the titular Teacup, a shy and introverted young frog who loves drinking tea and reading. The day before she is to host a tea party at her house, she realizes she is completely out of tea, and thus must venture into the woods around her to find the herbs she needs to restock her pantry. During your adventure you will meet the charming inhabitants of the forest. Some are talkative, some are grumpy, but all of them will lend you an ear on your adventure. Explore this gorgeous watercolor world filled with friendly animals, playful minigames, puzzles, and beautiful, calming wilderness.


  • nonlinear
  • scroller
  • cute
  • exploration
  • adventure
  • narrative
  • relaxing
  • horror
  • family-friendly
  • colourful
  • coffee
  • story
  • non-linear
  • funny
  • 2d

Not seeing your game?